Class Notes 11/13/2017

Latin American history and culture:

Relief efforts for the hurricane-inflicted devastation on the US Virgin Islands are proceeding slowly, partially hindered by the current political climate. 73% of the islands still lack electricity and plant life is effectively gone. Businesses and homes have sustained enormous damage, and the buildings that survived are often waterlogged and moldy. To this day, the Virgin Islands have lingering effects from colonialism such as old, ruined buildings and poverty.

Class:

  • Both the New and Old worlds contribute to the “Trans-Atlantic Story” of interaction
  • The European Enlightenment affects both sides of the Atlantic in the 18th century
    • John Locke was an important Enlightenment thinker
    • emphasis was placed on reason and observation to obtain information
    • creation of humanism: emphasis on individual natural rights
    • rise in secularism and republicanism/classical liberalism
  • The Bourbon Reforms (1713-1762)
    • Were they full-blown reforms, or simply a series of administrative changes?
    • Initiated by Philip V of Spain (reigned 1700-1746), first king of the new Bourbon dynasty
    • the power of the king in the colonies is always limited by intermediaries
    • inspired by the Enlightenment
    • administrative:
      • power of Criollos is curtailed, more power given to peninsulares
      • selling of offices is prohibited, making it more difficult for Criollos to rise through the ranks and decreasing social mobility
    • economic:
      • tax system is redesigned to be more efficient
      • attempt are made to regulate wages
      • government maintains monopolies on certain goods such as tobacco and gunpowder
      • loosening of trade restrictions (partially attributable to concessions from the Spanish War of Succession) increases Atlantic trade overall
    • social:
      • government exerts more control over the Catholic Church
      • influx of peninsulares
  • Pedro de Ayarza
    • respected Panamanian merchant racially labeled as pardo
    • sued to purchase official “whiteness” and honorific “don” for himself and his sons from 1795 to 1807 after his eldest was denied a university degree due to being pardo
    • fails to get title of “don,” succeeds in receiving “whiteness” for himself and one of his sons with his youngest being denied on account of age
    • this story shows how, in a legal sense, “whiteness” grants social mobility and allows a family to cast off racial stigma, but it is very expensive to obtain

We were unable to talk about Juan Barbarin because we ran out of time.

Definitions:

  • Criollos/Creoles: American-born Spaniards
  • Peninsulares: Iberian-born Spaniards in America
  • Pardo: dark-skinned
  • Bourbon Reforms: a series of reforms (or administrative changes, depending on who you ask) in the Spanish colonies from roughly 1713-1762 performed under the Bourbon dynasty that permanently altered colonial government
  • Age of Revolutions: an era in history in which revolutionary fervor gripped numerous oppressed peoples, causing uprisings in such places as America, France, and Haiti
  • Honor: public reputation
  • Gracias al Sacar: official decree freeing one from the caste system; official recognition of someone’s “whiteness”

Miscellaneous:

  • peer reviews for audio slideshows have been assigned on moodle and are due on Wednesday, after which Professor Holt will give her own feedback
  • we will later study the breakdown of colonial authority by analyzing the Haitian War of Independence
  • Monday will be an in-class discussion on Haitian independence with emphasis on primary source analysis

Links:

The Enlightenment: https://www.britannica.com/topic/history-of-Europe/The-Enlightenment

The Bourbon Reforms: http://historyworldsome.blogspot.com/2013/11/bourbon-reforms-in-latin-america.html

Age of Revolutions: https://www.britannica.com/topic/history-of-Europe/The-age-of-revolution

Indigenous Chileans Acquitted of Deadly Arson

In 2013, landowner Bernard Luchsinger and his wife Vivianne McKay were killed and their bodies burnt in the Araucania region of south-central Chile. The couple had been involved in a land dispute with the local Mapuche indigenous community. The incident was labeled “a terrorist act” by Interior Minister Andres Chadwick, and President Sebastian Pinera personally visited the region to announce the deployment of eighty-four additional police officers to protect local landowners. On October 25, 2017, eleven Mapuches suspected of having carried out the attack were cleared by judges due to insufficient evidence.

Tensions between the 600,000-strong Mapuche and the Chilean government have grown increasingly stressed over the past few years. Mapuche extremists have carried out other attacks on residents and companies who they see as intruding on traditional lands. The killing of Luchsinger and McKay may have been related to the murder of Mapuche activist Matias Catrileo in 2008, who was shot and killed by police while participating in an occupation of land owned by Jorge Luchsinger — a cousin of Bernard Luchsinger.

The article paints modern Latin America as being violent and stuck in the past. It mentions how armed groups have launched other destructive arson attacks on buildings and vehicles, and it links the violence seen today to a Chilean military invasion in the 1800s. The portrayal of Latin America, specifically Chile, is not dissimilar to Iraq.

Throughout Colonial Latin American history, indigenous peoples were constantly oppressed and their land encroached upon by greedy colonists. Many natives resisted Spanish conquest, but all eventually fell under at least nominal Spanish domination. The colonial bureaucracy and judicial system were generally stacked against them. Now, however, it seems as though native peoples are receiving fairer treatment. Even if their land is still preyed upon by landowners and corporations, there are people who recognize their plight and they can turn to the courts for justice. Lingering hostilities have nonetheless erupted into violence, and the Luchsinger murders were not the first or last altercations resulting from this. With any luck, the extremists responsible will be brought to justice and existing grievances can be solved peacefully.

 

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-41756817

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-20917065

Quick intro

Hi everyone! My name is Trevin and I am a Junior Archaeology major from Chicago, Illinois. I am most active in the Catholic Newman Group, but also participate in the fencing and chess clubs. While my major is Archaeology, I am also passionate about History, especially the Classics, and hope to one day go on an archaeological excavation on an ancient Roman site.

In Colonial Latin America, I would most like to learn about the Spanish and Portuguese administrations in the Americas. How were they able to control such a vast area so far from their homelands for hundreds of years? What degree of autonomy was granted to local administrations? Was European dominance total, or were the natives and colonists never fully pacified? I hope to find answers to these questions and others through this course.